Blu-ray Review: Public Enemies

I ended my theatrical review of Public Enemies with the following line:

I am leaving room for this one to grow on me or slowly settle down to the middle, but one thing’s for certain, it had my wheels spinning and may likely end up an all-time classic of mine a few years down the line.

This is the approach I try to take to all films whether I like them out of the box or not, but this one in particular felt like a film that was either going to slowly attach itself or just die away quietly. My expectations, as with other Mann films such as Heat and Thief (unfortunately not Miami Vice), were that this one would improve upon repeated viewings and after watching Universal’s Blu-ray release it does just that. As a matter of fact I no longer have any doubts as to this film’s quality even if I think there is a better film to be made on the subject, but that isn’t to say I believe an alternative film should be a complete departure.

It’s my belief, had this film been about Melvin Purvis (Christian Bale) and his chase for Dillinger and where Purvis’s life and career went after catching the notorious criminal, you would have had a much more cohesive story and one hell of an ending. Just look up the life of Melvin Purvis when you get a chance and you’ll see what I mean. On top of that, you could still keep the majority of the great scenes from Public Enemies. Just a thought.

Focusing his attention on John Dillinger (Johnny Depp), Mann tells a story of a man with no eye for the future, at least not at the outset. Dillinger lives for today in hopes of having a good time tomorrow, how he gets there only depends on him and him alone. This makes for a cold atmosphere as Mann meticulously duplicates the 1930s all the way down to shooting in the actual locations for three of the film’s key scenes, all three of which are discussed in this disc’s special features. Rumors of disagreements between Mann and Depp made their rounds prior to and during the film’s release and I can only assume after watching the special features Christian Bale had no such complaints.

One thing’s for certain, and I get a similar feeling about David Fincher, Michael Mann loves authenticity and while the special features say Depp tried on a pair of Dillinger’s pants, it seems Bale was far more interested in Mann’s attention to detail. In one segment Bale is shown in photos at the house of Melvin Purvis’s son, asking questions and searching to learn more about the man he was about to portray. Depp mentions a personal curiosity when it comes to Dillinger, but it seems both Bale and Mann go well beyond Depp’s interest which is a particularly interesting insight into the making of Public Enemies you will get out of this Blu-ray.

As for this disc’s features you get a rather comprehensive and well-designed batch of making-of featurettes as well as in-feature extras. On top of a rather exhaustive and informative commentary track from Mann you also get the feature length picture-in-picture U Control feature and an interactive historical timeline that plays along with the film. The timeline isn’t packed with information, but it does come with some fascinating archival videos and information that should prove interesting to anyone looking for more background. The picture-in-picture offers behind-the-scenes video and interviews that aren’t available elsewhere, which is a bit of a change up for Universal’s U Control which typically offers edited down segments from the included featurettes.

The featurettes are mostly short, concise and to the point, which in my book is all good. Only one of them, “Michael Mann: Making Public Enemies,” is over 20 minutes and it is the primary making of doc while the others are far more focused. The following four featurettes are no longer than 10 minutes each. “Last of the Legendary Outlaws” is specific to Dillinger while “Larger than Life: Adversaries” looks at the men that inspired the film. My favorites were easily “On Dillinger’s Trail: The Real Locations,” which gave a look at how they used the actual locations to recreate Dillinger’s prison break, the shootout at Little Bohemia and the exterior of the Biograph theater. The other is “Criminal Technology,” which looks at the weapons tech from the ’30s as well as the cars the gangsters used and how they had the police outmatched as a result.

Finally there is a “Gangster Movie Challenge” offering up trivia questions for five of Universal’s gangster titles including Public Enemies, American Gangster, Casino, Carlito’s Way and Scarface.

In my opinion this is an obvious buy, but I enjoyed the movie in theaters and enjoyed it even more on Blu-ray. Shot in high definition Public Enemies looks brilliant on the format, but some people saw Mann’s decision to shoot in HD as a drawback so that is up to your personal taste because nothing is lost on this transfer. It also makes use of a spectacular DTS audio track, which only enhances the terrific score by Elliot Goldenthal and the thundering mix of weaponry.

I have a few problems with this film, but I’m not here saying it’s great, simply that it’s a film I am happy is on my shelf space and recommend you consider adding to yours.

Stay up to date with everything Home Video related from reviews, release dates and newly announced DVDs and Blu-ray Discs in the RopeofSilicon Home Video Central.


Marvel and DC