Why Pluribus Fans Think Carol Killed Helen

An interesting theory suggests that Carol might have killed Helen in Pluribus. The first episode, titled “We is Us,” follows Carol’s arrival in Albuquerque. She witnesses those around her suddenly convulsing, including her partner, Helen. Amid the chaos, Carol rushes Helen to the hospital, only to learn that everyone is infected. Tragically, Helen doesn’t survive, though the exact cause of her death is never explicitly revealed.

Did Carol actually kill Helen on Pluribus?

An ongoing theory claims that Carol might be responsible for Helen’s demise on Pluribus.

The theory suggests that the virus may not have caused Helen’s death, but rather Carol’s careless actions while rushing her to the hospital. In Episode 1, everyone around them is struck by the virus, losing consciousness and suffering convulsions. However, the virus only temporarily shuts down the body, with people regaining consciousness shortly after. In Helen’s case, she was affected by the virus but never came back like the others.

Carol was nowhere near Helen when the virus hit her, as she was fearfully watching everyone around her collapse. When she sees Helen fall to the ground, she panics and rushes toward her. Worried about Helen’s condition, Carol quickly tries to get her into the car to take her to the hospital. According to the theory, her careless attempt to move her may have ultimately caused Helen’s demise.

The theory claims that Helen’s fall on the pavement might have caused significant brain trauma, an injury that could have been treated later and might have saved her. However, the way Carol moved her so violently while rushing her to the hospital may have erased those chances. This is because a person who has suffered a head trauma shouldn’t be moved, as the injury can shift to the vertebrae and trigger nerve damage. This can lead to paralysis, serious medical complications, and, in many cases, death.