Movie Reviews

Twilight

Reviewed by: Edward Douglas
Rating:
4.5 out of 10
Movie Details:
View here

Cast:
Kristen Stewart as Bella Swan
Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen
Billy Burke as Charlie Swan
Ashley Greene as Alice Cullen
Nikki Reed as Rosalie Hale
Jackson Rathbone as Jasper Hale
Kellan Lutz as Emmet Cullen
Peter Facinelli as Dr. Carlisle Cullen
Cam Gigandet as James
Taylor Lautner as Jacob Black
Anna Kendrick as Jessica Stanley
Michael Welch as Mike Newton
Justin Chon as Eric Yorkie
Christian Serratos as Angela Weber
Gil Birmingham as Billy Black
Elizabeth Reaser as Esme Cullen
Edi Gathegi as Laurent
Rachelle Lefevre as Victoria
Sarah Clarke as Renee
Ned Bellamy as Waylon Forge
Gregory Tyree Boyce as Tyler
Matt Bushell as Phil
José Zúñiga as Mr. Molina

Directed by Catherine Hardwicke

Summary:
Essentially, a CW take on Anne Rice, catering to the gooey-eyed fans of Meyer's novels and their unrealistic romantic expectations.

Story:
After moving to Washington State to live with her police chief father, Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) tries to adjust to a new high school and her exceedingly strange lab partner Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson), who seems to be turned off by her, but in fact, has a deep, dark secret… he's a vampire… who likes to play baseball.

Analysis:
Maybe I'm giving away my age or my gender or the fact I haven't read a single word that Stephenie Meyer has ever written either intentionally or by accident, so going to see this movie without any advance knowledge, even avoiding all trailers and clips, might not have been the best way to see it. (Maybe this reviewer is trying to learn from his experience with "Nick and Nora's Infinite Playlist.") If this movie is someone's first taste of Meyer's mediocre Harlequin vampire romance, one might be left somewhat mystified how it's been turned into such a global phenomenon, as enticing to women as catnip is to cats.

On the surface, there's very little difference between this and teen-minded dogs like "The Covenant" or "Blood and Chocolate" or even a less entertaining "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" with better production values. Yet any gleeful desire one might have to tear apart and analyze every aspect of the movie serves little purpose, because let's face it, nothing anyone can say or do could possibly convince the millions of women who've already bought their opening day tickets to ask for a refund.

The film's set-up is straight out of the pilot of far too many teen-oriented TV dramas. Kristen Stewart's Bella Swan moves to a new neighborhood and tries to make new friends on her first day of school at the denizens of a local high school. The weirdest clique at this school is the Cullen family, five sophisticated teens whom keep to themselves. When Bella first makes visual contact with Robert Pattinson's Edward Cullen, sparks immediately fly, but he pushes her away and tries to keep her at arm's length, much to Bella's annoyance. A freak accident puts Bella's life in danger and Edward miraculously saves her, and Bella starts to wonder if there's more to the strange boy than just his rude behavior, and she starts digging into the truth about Edward and his family. It'll take the next hour for her to figure things out… are the Cullens vampires or werewolves or aliens or are they just a weird incestuous family who wear too much pancake make-up, drive cool cars and act weird around others? By the time the "v" word is actually used, you wonder how no one else in town has figured it out by now.

The movie's biggest problem is that the two main actors don't have enough personality to keep the movie interesting. Stewart's slightly better in her "bored cool" monotonic delivery she's perfected, while Pattinson's strengths lies in his ability to brood and throw longing looks at his leading lady. Whomever thought Cedric Diggory could play a leading man like this one was surely going merely by his looks, which would be par for the course for a movie that's all surface with little depth. The two actors have very little chemistry, spending much of the movie acting awkward around each other, because after all, Edward can't be in love with a human; that would be like a guy falling in love with his juicy hamburger. No, these are immortal vampires sworn not to drink human blood, so instead they act strange, glitter like sparkle in the sunlight and play baseball in thunderstorms. Yes, you read that last part right.

The rest of the young cast aren't bad--it's certainly nice seeing indie up 'n' comers like Anna Kendrick and others being used well--but the movie bogs itself down with over-exposition, especially while following Bella's search for the truth about Edward. The bland writing does very little to keep one interested, though there are some funny bits involving Bella's male friends and their interest in her, plus Billy Burke does get some genuine laughs as her overprotective father, but otherwise, the humor is mostly inside jokes for the sake of those who read the books. Most of the movie is sooooo high school that after a while, one can't help feeling that director Catherine Hardwicke needs to stop playing with teens and start playing with people her own age.

It takes a good ninety minutes for the "bad vampires," the ones that act normal by killing and eating humans, to show up and face "Team Edward." Thankfully, we're spared an actual baseball game between the two factions and are given a passing introduction to James (Cam Cigandet), the bad guy who also sets his eye on Bella as the target for his desire to hunt and kill his food. It's just bad storytelling to wait so long to properly introduce such a major character and after Bella and Edward are chased across the country to escape, he's disposed of so easily, one wonders why even bother introducing any antagonist into the situation. Even so, that doesn't stop Hardwicke from setting up the next movie, which one can probably figure out by who's left standing.

One can give Hardwicke suitable credit for finding an excellent DP in Elliot Davis, who makes every shot look stunning, whether it's the panoramic vistas of Oregon (doubling for Washington) or the tight close-ups on the intensity of the two leads. It was also a smart decision hiring Carter Burwell to do the score, embellishing the film's soundtrack, which is certainly its strong suit, as you would expect from a movie trying to cater to the CW generation. The entire movie just relies too much on the slick commercial look of the movie rather than the quality of the performances or pacing of the storytelling, the latter possibly being faulted to their desire to be faithful to Meyer's source.

The movie's production values falter tragically when it comes to the action scenes, as few as there are, mostly done using sloppy wirework and poorly-executed time-lapsing FX to show Edward using his super-speed. It's embarrassing how bad the scenes look considering the money at Hardwicke's disposal, compared to Asian action films like "Kung Fu Hustle" which look amazing at a fraction of that cost. Fortunately, the women going to see this movie won't really care about that, as long as they get a scene of Bella and Edward swooning over each other afterwards. Actual fans of vampire movies looking for any amount of blood-rending terror will be thoroughly disappointed by the innocuous way the violence is handled in the movie.

What really worries me is that movies like this one (and Meyer's books) set up unrealistic expectations for young women about romance, while making it impossible for real guys to live up to the standards set by Edward, who is just ridiculously and incredulously perfect in every way. Even so, with all of the throbbing unconsummated sexual energy permeating the movie, one can probably expect teen pregnancy to explode in the coming months as girls try to find the romantic intimacy of Bella and Edward and spend the rest of their lives being disappointed by reality.

The Bottom Line:
As much as the movie works as a showcase for Hardwicke and her crew to create a movie that looks great, the problems of the source material and its weak pacing are hard to overcome with flashy visuals and music. As someone watching it without having read the books, it's hard to understand the appeal, but it doesn't really matter. If one really must see a vampire love story this weekend, they should skip this and go see "Let the Right One In."

| 90 comments | Add a comment

COMMENTS (90)

Posted by:
Ace
November 20, 2008
Yeah that's why most of the times I don't like watching "girl" movies with my girlfriend cause in those movies the guy is always the perfect fairytales prince lol.
Posted by:
Max
November 20, 2008
I can't speak for the film, but as a male who has read all of Stephanie Meyer's books (including "The Host," which is full of heavily flawed men and is unrelated to the Twilight Saga), I can say for sure that Edward as portrayed in the books is NOT perfect (same goes for Jacob Black, who becomes a rival love interest for Bella in the sequels). His flaws are more pronounced in the 2nd and 3rd novels, but they are certainly present in the 1st as well. It's a bit presumptuous to think that what appears onscreen is one and the same with what's in the book, or that what you perceive as the film's failings are in fact the failings of Meyer's novel, and not of the screenwriter.
Posted by:
Axel
November 20, 2008
"Essentially, a CW take on Anne Rice, catering to the gooey-eyed fans of Meyer's novels and their unrealistic romantic expectations."

I am not at all the demographic for this film but I am curious why you feel the need to talk down to the fans of the books as well as the upcoming film.

Why do their romatic expectations have to be labled as unrealistic?
Posted by:
Damien
November 20, 2008
In your review, you wrote "Even so, with all of the throbbing unconsummated sexual energy permeating the movie, one can probably expect teen pregnancy to explode in the coming months as girls try to find the romantic intimacy of Bella and Edward and spend the rest of their lives being disappointed by reality." It's been a long time since I've been a teenager, but I nonetheless found myself offended by that statement, and it's underlying assumption that teenagers are stupid. This is a FICTIONAL film. You are essentially saying that teenagers, or, more precisely, teenage females, can't distinguish between fact and fiction, which will lead them to take a film about VAMPIRES literally. Ageism and sexism wrapped in a bow of condescension. How incredibly arrogant.
Posted by:
somethin
November 20, 2008
HELL YEAH MAN. Let the Right One in. Is superior to this in every way.
Posted by:
Ethan Everett
November 20, 2008
"What really worries me is that movies like this one (and Meyer's books) set up unrealistic expectations for young women about romance, while making it impossible for real guys to live up to the standards set by Edward, who is just ridiculously and incredulously perfect in every way. Even so, with all of the throbbing unconsummated sexual energy permeating the movie, one can probably expect teen pregnancy to explode in the coming months as girls try to find the romantic intimacy of Bella and Edward and spend the rest of their lives being disappointed by reality."

Spot on, Edward. And Damien, it may sound silly and somehow offensive... but it's sadly true. We're not trying to be sexist or anything like that. It's just that teenage girls are being very stupid, and very loose these days. Too many get caught up in this fantasy world that they engulf themselves in. And they will honestly look for an Edward. And they will give up anything (ANYTHING) to find/get one. And the worst type of guys know this.. and they will use it to their horrible advantage to get the girls in bed and then dispose of them. They'll use lines from "Twilight" to get girls into their bed (I'm hearing girls SWOOON over this "you're my world now" line). 14-16 year old girls aren't exactly aware of how harsh and horrible some of the people in this world are. And if they are told that they can never find an Edward, then their minds will refuse to believe it and they'll go against whoever told them that to rebel and try to prove them wrong. And then they the girls will be proven wrong. But it's the honest truth. Even the best guy you could find will never be as good as Edward. These books are just setting way too high of expectations for girls. And that's sad and disappointing and irritating.

Not everyone is as smart as you think, Damien. Sure, I know some girls that already know about how unrealistic these books are (which is why they avoid them). But there are obviously girls that don't know the truth. Why do you think these girls keep reading these books? The fantasy becomes their ideal dream and their dream becomes a mission.

It's true. It's sad, but it's true.
Posted by:
Axel
November 20, 2008
It cracks me up when a romantic fantasy movie aimed at teenage girls comes out and men have to say that it will turn them into loose women and they will try to make the movie their reality.

Ethan for someone not trying to sound sexist, you sound pretty sexist and ignorant to say that that teenage girls are being very stupid, and very loose these days.
Posted by:
Axel
November 20, 2008
You never hear an outcry that stupid teenage boys will try to emulate what they see in a American Pie type film.
Posted by:
Abe
November 20, 2008
Ethan and Edward: Amen. Reading this review helped me further understand why I dislike all this bs... but my girlfriend won't understand.
Posted by:
Michelle
November 20, 2008
The problem with this critique of the movie is in teh first sentence: YOU HAVEN"T READ THE BOOKS, so you giving a critique is just rediculous. This movie is not about the action scenes. I don;t understand why people don't get this!!! Sorry, but the movie is about how Bella and Edward's love develops and how truely hard it is for them to love each other. That is why they are awkward around each other and their acting is the way it is. And to say the two have no chemistry is just rediculous. In interviews Hardwicke said that Stewart and Pattinson had such great chemistry there was no way she could pair Stewart with one of the other guys there. So maybe you should read the books before you judge.

The only thing that I do agree with you on is the fact that there are too many crazy girls going around saying they are only going to settle for "Edward".

ADD COMMENTS

NAME: COMMENTS:
E-MAIL:
Security Code:
Remember my name/e-mail address
Follow ComingSoon.net on Twitter
MOST ACTIVE

New Moon Breaks Dark Knight's Single Day Record
50 new posts | 90 total posts

The Twilight Saga: New Moon - What Did You Think?!
15 new posts | 199 total posts

New Kull Movie in the Works
7 new posts | 11 total posts

New Colonel Quaritch Featurette for Avatar!
6 new posts | 11 total posts

New Moon Breaks Midnight Opening Record!
3 new posts | 141 total posts

The Twilight Saga: New Moon
3 new posts | 28 total posts

Winnie
2 new posts | 2 total posts

Idris Elba to Play Heimdall in Thor
2 new posts | 44 total posts

Domestic Trailer for Percy Jackson & The Olympians
2 new posts | 19 total posts

The Twilight Saga: New Moon
2 new posts | 14 total posts

Lyndsy Fonseca Hops in Hot Tub Time Machine
2 new posts | 8 total posts

Little Fockers
1 new posts | 28 total posts