Movie Reviews

The Namesake

Reviewed by: Edward Douglas
Rating: 5.5 out of 10
Movie Details: View here

Cast:
Kal Penn as Gogol Ganguli
Irfan Khan as Ashoke Ganguli
Tabu as Ashima Ganguli
Jacinda Barrett as Maxine Ratliff
Zuleikha Robinson as Moushumi Mazumdar
Sahira Nair as Sonia Ganguli
Glenne Headly as Lydia Ratliff
Daniel Gerroll as Gerald Ratliff
Jagannath Guha as Ghosh
Ruma Guha Thakurta as Ashoke's Mother
Sukanya as Rini
Tanusree Shankar as Ashima's Mother
Supriya Choudhury as Ashima's Grandmother
Sabyasachi Chakravarthy as Ashima's Father
Tamal Sengupta as Ashoke's Father
Dhruv Mookerji as Rana
Michael Countryman as Mr. Wilcox
Kousik Bhowal as Dr. Gupta
Soham Chatterjee as Gogol (Age 4)
Noor Lahiri Vourvoulias as Baby Sonia
Gargi Mukherjee as Mira Mashi
Pallavi Shah as Kajol Mashi
Jhumpa Lahiri as Jhumpa Mashi
Linus Roache as Mr. Lawson
B.C. Parekh as Mr. Mazumdar
Sibani Biswas as Mrs. Mazumdar
Kharaj Mukherjee as Chotu

Directed by Mira Nair

Summary:
What should have been a home run for Nair is an unfocused mess of a movie that tries to tell a complex cross-generational story of two cultures, but fails to really capture or keep one's interest.

Story:
Ashima (Tabu) was married to Ashoke Ganguli (Irfan Khan) at an early age as part of an arranged marriage that brought her to New York from Calcutta. Their son, the unfortunately named Gogol (Kal Penn), rebels against the family traditions and moves away from the family as soon as he can, taking his second name Nick rather than having to explain why he's called "Gogol." When his father dies, he decides to embrace his family traditions, traveling back to Calcutta to discover why his father gave him such an untraditional name.

Analysis:
On paper, having Indo-American filmmaking pioneer Mira Nair adapt Jhumpa Lahiri's generational tale "The Namesake" into a film, reuniting her with "Mississippi Masala" screenwriter Sonni Taraporevala, would sound like an easy home run, so why this movie fails so miserably is something that might someday be studied and analyzed in further depth than this review.

While the novel was primarily about Gogol, the film starts back in Calcutta where his young mother Ashima (Tabu) is married for prestige not love to Ashoke Ganguli, an engineer who brings her back to America, then leaves her alone to deal with her new environment and culture. Eventually, they have kids, and their son has to deal with being mocked for being given the odd name of "Gogol" by his father after the Russian writer Nikolai Gogol who had some impact on his life. Rebelling against his father and his heritage, Gogol moves to Manhattan and takes on his second name "Nick" while dating Maxine (Jacinda Barrett), a beautiful non-Indian girl from a wealthy family who can't see past "Nick's" race. When something happens to his father, Gogol reverts back to his given name, returning to Calcutta to embrace his heritage and the customs of his family, dumping Maxine for the jet-setting Indo-American Moushumi, who fits in more with his new lifestyle.

Like Nair's previous films, "The Namesake" is a fine glimpse into Indian culture and tradition with an informed perspective on the Indian immigrant experience and the differences between cultures. Lahiri's novel was more about Gogol, and the trailer is a bit deceptive in that it makes it seem like the movie is similarly about Kal Penn's character. It's somewhat vexing that Penn doesn't actually show up until about 40 minutes into the film. Instead, the movie's just as much about Ashima and her relationship with Ashoke, who doesn't come across very well in the way he treats the beautiful new wife poorly and ignores her while she's adjusting to life in America.

Other than that, this isn't a particularly interesting story and there's no real flow to the storytelling. Granted, some of the plot problems come from the book, but it wasn't the smartest move to take a linear approach when adapting the story. Early in the movie, there's a scene of Ashoke surviving a deadly train accident in India, which is quickly forgotten until 90 minutes later, when it's used to explain why his son after Russian writer Nikolai Gogol. By then, it seems to be trying to get back on track with the novel and it would have been more effective to save the origin of Gogol's name for the end of the movie. One would think that someone with Nair's experience would understand that mixing things up with flashbacks can often be more interesting, but the way the movie jumps between Gogol and his mother in the second half makes it hard to really get into either of their characters.

Penn is better known for the hilarious comic roles he played in movies like "Harold & Kumar" and "Van Wilder," but he ends up overcompensating to play serious drama and in doing so, comes across rather stiff. On the other hand, gorgeous Indian superstar Tabu is excellent as his mother, making her arc more interesting in some ways, as she literally ages on screen from this beautiful young woman to this wisened middle-age woman. She's a real standout in the cast, often rising above the weak writing and cheap melodrama.

The inherent beauty of India is often on display in the scenes shot in Calcutta and around the Taj Mahal, but there's a real disconnect with the scenes in America, which look drab and boring by comparison. Sure, it's meant to show a contrast between the cultures, but the inconsistent quality of the film's look is as erratic and unfocused as the film itself. There's also a mixed message as Gogol's new Indian wife has an affair, making you wonder whether embracing his heritage was such a good idea after all.

The Bottom Line:
The big shame about "The Namesake" is that there's probably a good movie in there somewhere, but despite its strong themes and a few interesting ideas, the film is tedious and unfocused, basically two hours of meandering tedium, a real mess. One would expect better from a filmmaker with Mira Nair's talent and experience.

From Around the Web

comments powered by Disqus
Follow ComingSoon.net on Twitter
MOST ACTIVE
From our partners