Movie News

Academy Disqualifies The Dark Knight Score

Source:Variety
November 13, 2008


Variety reports that the score for The Dark Knight has been disqualified by the executive committee of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences music branch from being considered for an Oscar.

Formal letters to that effect are expected to go out this week to composers Hans Zimmer and James Newton Howard, who collaborated on the music.

Their previous collaboration, on Batman Begins, was similarly disqualified in 2005.

According to the trade, the big issue was the fact that five names were listed as composers on the music cue sheet, the official studio document that specifies every piece of music (along with its duration and copyright owner) in the film.

Zimmer previously said that listing multiple names on the cue sheet was a way of financially rewarding parts of the music team who helped make the overall work successful.

Zimmer, Howard and the other three individuals -- music editor Alex Gibson, ambient music designer Mel Wesson and composer Lorne Balfe -- reportedly signed an affidavit stating that the score was primarily the work of Zimmer and Howard.

That apparently wasn't enough for the majority of the committee, which was also supplied with documentation indicating that more than 60%, but less than 70%, of the score was credited to Zimmer and Howard.

COMMENTS (107)

Posted by:
mangatron
November 13, 2008
The hell? Now what, they think the soundtrack was from Batman Begins? tsk tsk....

Which is sort of in a way,....
Posted by:
Hans Zimmer
November 13, 2008
are you kidding..... the dark knight score was tremendous this is ridiculous
Posted by:
Mitchell
November 13, 2008
This is why the average movie fan hates the Oscars. Whenever a quality movie comes along enjoyed by a majority of people, the Oscar committees find someone of making sure their precisous little indies win as many oscars as possible. Every movie deserves a chance for an award and this is just another way for movie critics to say their better than the rest of us common bumpkins who actually watch movie for entertainment and not art.
Posted by:
Kyle Kelley
November 13, 2008
I think that they are pissing on there work for not qualifying the score. They better not dis-qualify Heath Ledger for his OSCAR....
Posted by:
IT WAS NOT ALL THAT
November 13, 2008
Hans Zimmer is a genius and the score provided plenty of suspense to the film.

But, let's face reality, it sucked compared the the awesome 89' Batman score. Just saying.

It' not a memorable score like the Superman or Batman 89' scores are. Can you hum it from great memory like the Superman score? Thought so.
Posted by:
Scott
November 13, 2008
First the problems with the foreign language award last year, and they continue to have trouble with original score (lest we forget Johnny Greenwood).

Disappointing...hopefully this won't be the first of many shafts at the Oscars for TDK.
Posted by:
Harrison Ford
November 13, 2008
That's ridiculous, the score was amazing!

Oooh look at us, we're the academy, we can do whatever we want.

Stupid power hungry old people
Posted by:
Ash
November 13, 2008
Well, I fail to see why we can't watch movies for both entertainment AND art...

That is not to say that I agree with the Academy's decision.
Posted by:
Bob
November 13, 2008
f-ckers
way to continue their reign of suckage
Posted by:
Nuts
November 13, 2008
Wow, did anyone actually read the article above?
No KIDDING it was an incredible score...they're disqualifying it because the award normally goes to a composer that claims at least 70% of the writing credit...not a group of 5 great composers who're each credited with less.

Hey, I'm eternally pissed too...but they don't want to award an Oscar to a composer that didnt' write the whole thing.

ADD COMMENTS

NAME: COMMENTS:
E-MAIL:
Security Code: Write the word seven:
Remember my name/e-mail address

Latest Headlines:

Scream 4's Ghostface Spotted!
J.J. Abrams to Produce Boilerplate Adaptation
Exclusive Charlie St. Cloud Interviews
SDCC EXCLUSIVE: Walt Disney Studios' Sean Bailey
Kristen Johnston Joins Vamps
First Image of Super's Crimson Bolt
SDCC: Exclusive Saw 3D Interview
Len Wiseman to Direct Total Recall
New Featurette and Poster for Disney's Tangled
On the Red Carpet with Jay Roach and His Schmucks
Rob Schneider Voices Norm of the North
Sasha Grey Will Melt with You
Guillermo del Toro Finally Enters the Mountains of Madness
Lindelof Doing Rewrites on Alien Prequel?
Yogi Bear Trailer Debuts
Crosshair Begins Film Development
SDCC: The Marvel Studios Panel!
Robert Duvall, Bill Murray and Sissy Spacek Get Low

Follow ComingSoon.net on Twitter