kieran
05-23-2005, 07:42 PM
(Originally posted by PADAWAN331) Where can i start.I' am so dissapointed with this film,it isnt what expected it to be.This film left more questions than answers.The acting was great and the main characters played their parts well,but god sakes there isnt any continuity.Gl creates these villians and then kills them off with ease,whats up with that?.I dont think Anakins turning to the darkside was so convincing at all,in order for it to be anyway near convincing the movie would have to be at least 3 hours long.As for the connection between anakin and padme there were none.The connection with anakin and obiwan was ok it could have been better.I just feel that there should have been more emotion.The connection btw anakin and palpatine was good but then again it could have been better.The fight scenes were good,but two short.This all goes back to episode I,Darthmaul-such a cool character and you kill him off.Then count dooku,he lasted long but to kill him off quick in episode III there isnt any justice in killing off a charater who has evaded the jedi the he has.Then there is General Grievous who is supose to be the new villian of episode III (before anakin becomes the main one),the gl killed him off was so corny i mean this guy didnt even do much in the film,so much hype for nothing.Now the fight scene btw mace windu and palpatine was ok,but then again it could have been better and longer there was no justification to maces death,such an all powerful jedi to die the way he did ,come'on.GL just doesnt know how to put characters to an end.Then there is the fight scene btw yoda and sidious,that fight was awesome but the way it ended was corny,yoda fleas come'on.Then there is the duel,the final duel so to speak.This duel was ok but to take obiwan and anakin and have them jumping around all over the place instead of keeping it on the ground was in my opinon kind of lame it took away the spark from the duel.Then everyone was complaining that this film is to graphic ,Hey not an ounce of blood present.Then you have the death of padme-Her physical state is ok but she is dying of reasons we cannot explain-is this how you going to explain her death to all the sw fans,in my opinion no explanation was given.Oh, no Qui-Gonn Jinn might i add .Then there is the transition from the prequals to the original sw at the end of episode III which i thought was pretty stupid.In all this movie needed to be at least,let me capitalize this-THIS MOVIE NEEDED TO BE AT LEAST 3 HOURS LONG TO COVER EVERYTHING,everything was just done in a rush and you can tell as you watch the film.As the film ended and the credits went up everyone cheered and clapped,but i was so dissapointed with the film and with gl.This movie is just a big I dont know to me.
Action:6/10
love scenes: 4/10
deaths: 2/10
Anakins turn to the darside: 3/10
special effects:10/10
explanations: 1/10
overall: I give this film 5/10 IT COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER PERIOD!!!!!!!!!!
WHAT?????????????????????????????????????????????? ????????????????????
This film shat on TPM from a million squillion miles!! TPM was a joke of a movie. A 6 year old Ani, stupid talking lizard creatures, zero casulties, plot holes, dreadfull acting. I could go on and on. Can anybody give me an intelligent explanation as to why it was better? :confused: :confused: :confused: :confused:
__________________
Action:6/10
love scenes: 4/10
deaths: 2/10
Anakins turn to the darside: 3/10
special effects:10/10
explanations: 1/10
overall: I give this film 5/10 IT COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER PERIOD!!!!!!!!!!
WHAT?????????????????????????????????????????????? ????????????????????
This film shat on TPM from a million squillion miles!! TPM was a joke of a movie. A 6 year old Ani, stupid talking lizard creatures, zero casulties, plot holes, dreadfull acting. I could go on and on. Can anybody give me an intelligent explanation as to why it was better? :confused: :confused: :confused: :confused:
__________________