PDA

View Full Version : Length/Time Questions

Indy4
06-07-2004, 06:27 PM
In ROTK, there are two errors, when they show the beacons it looks like a HUGE distance.

Over countrys

but it only took Theodon a few days to go across.

Whats with that?

and when they get Faramir's body, it takes only a few seconds while it took some minutes for Gandalf too ride up with Shadowfax

maybe this is just nit picky

but true
Andrey83
06-07-2004, 06:36 PM
Well, they used one day to the camp.

And then 3 days gallop. Thats pretty far ;)

Actually its very far.

And just because they dont show the whole thing, doesnt meen it didnt happen :) (about that faramir body)
Indy4
06-07-2004, 06:57 PM
also

There is a audio issue, dont know if its just 2.1 speakers

but with 2.1 Theodan

says

and the world is end......

doesnt say ending

will that be fixed in the EE or is that just an 2.1 problem?
Andrey83
06-07-2004, 07:50 PM
Maybe a 2.1 issue. Not sure.

I watched it on 5.1 and everything was normal.

Not sure what that can be.

If this is a 2.1 issue (for all), then it will most likely be fixed in the EE.
dustindame
06-07-2004, 08:21 PM
Originally posted by Indy4
In ROTK, there are two errors, when they show the beacons it looks like a HUGE distance.

Over countrys

but it only took Theodon a few days to go across.

Whats with that?

and when they get Faramir's body, it takes only a few seconds while it took some minutes for Gandalf too ride up with Shadowfax

maybe this is just nit picky

but true

I dont think those are errors. IMO

Because everything pretty much adds up.
Necross
06-07-2004, 11:29 PM
Those aren't mistakes at all, your way to nitpicky Indy, would you really wanted them to waste time showing them carry Faramir up the levels of Minas Tirith? As for the beacons, I see no mistake, yeah they traveled a far distance but so did Theoden. As for the Theoden speech thing, I hear the World's Ending every time.
PsYkOoOoO
06-08-2004, 12:45 AM
Yeah,Nitpicking.

Thats the only valid explaination...
adt100
06-08-2004, 12:12 PM
You're getting more needlessly 'nit-picky' than KenM these days Indy4! ;)

The only solution - complete LOTR viewing session of all 3 TC DVD back-to-back, followed by the EE's of FOTR and TTT. :D