Single LOTR movie

[ip_guru]

Hey all, sorry if this has been asked, I don't get in here too much.....

Is there any talk of a single LOTR movie on DVD, without cutting?

Just curious.... Thanks.

[JEDI_THE_WHITE]

Don't believe so.


Although there is talk of reediting the films so that they seem even more like one big film.


Fran Walsh and Phillipa Boyens wanted to do a chronological version of the films and put everything in order.

[Andrey83]

They talked about it on one of the comentaries...

1.000.000 bucks it will never happen ;)

[Brock Landers]

Originally posted by JEDI_THE_WHITE
Don't believe so.


Although there is talk of reediting the films so that they seem even more like one big film.


Fran Walsh and Phillipa Boyens wanted to do a chronological version of the films and put everything in order.

That'd be really really cool(the chronological cut, that is).

[Necross]

What do they mean Chronological? Like make the flash bacsk NOT flash backs?

[Brock Landers]

Originally posted by Necross
What do they mean Chronological? Like make the flash bacsk NOT flash backs?

Say, like, the scene with Boromir/Faramir/Denethor at Osgiliath would be somewhere in FOTR. The entire movie running in the order they happened in time. So yes, no flashbacks.

[dustindame]

I wont buy this if it did come out, i can live with just getting all my movies and switching the discs in between each movie.

[Brock Landers]

I'd rent, because the entire idea of it is very interesting. It'd be worth a look. I'm quite happy with my TC & EE's of each film(when I get the EE of ROTK in November, of course) ;)

[Indy4]

when HD-DVD's come out and the HD-DVD versions of LOTR comes out

there will most defenetly be a custom made LOTR version to download, a bootleg of course

but its what your asking for

[The Moose]

i reckon that a chronlogical movie would eb very interesting. but i severely doubt that it will ever be done

[Indy4]

it will defenetly happen

forgot to state that for Two Towers

some guy realesed a purist edition without any elves at helms deep and faramir with the ring and osgiliath,

so yeah 99.99% chance this will happen

[Andrey83]

Originally posted by Indy4
it will defenetly happen

forgot to state that for Two Towers

some guy realesed a purist edition without any elves at helms deep and faramir with the ring and osgiliath,

so yeah 99.99% chance this will happen

Wtf are you talking about? So on the wall there is only aragorn, gimli and leggy? Nah, doubt it ;)

[Indy4]

check it out

http://p211.ezboard.com/fthelotrmoviesitearwendebate.showMessage?topicID=1 62.topic

http://www.thelastfreecity.com/TheZionSwitchboard/messageview.cfm?catid=13&threadid=5045

its real

"Anyone familiar with the fan made 'Phantom Edit' version of Star Wars Episode One? Well, some dude has made a doctored version of TTT that improves (from the purist's point of view) upon Peter Jackson's cut. It removes 40 mins of Elves at Helm's Deep, Evil Faramirs, Retarded Ents etc."

[Andrey83]

Wow. thats is some nerd :)

Sounds borring. I love that the elves show up at Helmes Deep! ;)

[beyond_th3]

how could I get a hold of this "purists edit?"

[Necross]

Purist edit sounds terrible, worse than having the changes which I didn't think is bad. I would rather have changes then 15 minute chunks of the movie just randomly disappearing.

[adt100]

Exactly, but then you know what some of the raving purists are like. Many would rather have a poor film that was 'faithful' to the book (with regard changes more specifically than cuts), than a good film.