empire readers stupid vote

[big lebowski]

cos i was really bored last week i decided to buy march edition of empire as well as my usual total film (best film mag u can buy) and found inside of the empire mag a reader poll of the greatest films ever made- wat i read lead me to complete madness- according to the knowledgeable readers of empire mag lotr-fellowship of the ring is the greatest film ever made on top of that pirates of the carribean was a staggering 18 places above a true great one flew over the cuckoo's nest. any real film fans out there plz tell me im not goin crazy its just the rest of the world that wouldnt know a good film if it slapped them in the face

anyway to reconsile this just wanted to know wat u guys thought would be in the top 5 of greatest films ever made?

p.s sorry bout my spelling my keyboad is fcked

[spiderman_2k]

I was pissed to see T2 was in the #70's somewhere.

[Citizen Kane]

How awful.

Why, UK, why?

[droidguy1119]

Not America, UK. Empire Magazine is a British publication.

[spiderman_2k]

Yep....Damn Us...:mad:

[Citizen Kane]

Originally posted by droidguy1119
Not America, UK. Empire Magazine is a British publication.

How could I forget that? :o

It's my birthday's fault...somehow. :p

[Warren]

I like LOTR, but the trilogy does not deserve to be so high on a top movie list.

And POTC being over One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest is a horrible travesty.

[droidguy1119]

I never particularly believed jpdil's comments that Empire was as reliable as Entertainment Weekly.

[Tony Montana]

Stupid kiddy magazine... It is all fan based, nothing to bother about...

Who cares about that? The world would be very boring place without such clowns, so enjoy your time laughing...

[Se7en the movie]

personally empire is my magazine of choice, i cant stand the stupidity of total film

certainly i was surprised about LOTR as number 1 film but no matter what film was up there, i would bother someone......

[droidguy1119]

Only film magazine I trust is EW.

[moviegeek]

Originally posted by droidguy1119
Only film magazine I trust is EW. Same here.

[stage_tempest]

what do you expect? If you take any kind of poll whether it be music or movies, nine times out of ten the hit of the moment will make it into the top 5 and more than likely the number one position. It would be interesting to see if LOTR and POTC can sustain that kind of importance in viwer ratings when the hype has died down and we have new range of blockbuster films to entertain us.

[Inferno]

Originally posted by stage_tempest
nine times out of ten the hit of the moment will make it into the top 5 and more than likely the number one position.

Agreed. These top movies of all times lists should excluded any movie made in the last 5 years.