Did the derictor do any changes to the movie coming from the book?

[Harrypotterlotr]

Because I noticed a couple of changed scences in Two Towers I hope they don't do anything differnt to this movie I loved the book and hope the movie stays true to the book , just need your thoughts on this one , later :) .

[The Moose]

PJ has said that ROTK follows the book more closely than the other few things. we already know that Scouring of the Shire is out, as is Ghan buri Ghan. there are other characters which are alse questionable, such as Imrahil, Elladan and Elrohir and a few others

[Mirokai]

I hope PJ don’t change it because I really enjoy it just like it is!!:applaud:

[PsYkOoOoO]

ROTK follows the book more closely than the other 2 movies..

[Cloud Buster]

ROTK is easily my favorite book...and it's also the shortest. I don't think he'll need to make real signifigant changes other than those we know about (Scouring, Muster of Rohan). On Imrahil, we mentioned it somewhere else and although the jury's still out I think the consensus so far is that at the LEAST an appearance by Imrahil is possible.

WAIT: I just realized something. In the trailer, we see part of The Last Debate, where they decide to attack Mordor at Morannon (The Black Gate) to buy Frodo some time, and we're shown Gimli, Legolas, Gandalf, Eomer, and Aragorn. If Imrahil was going to play the part he played in the book, he'd be in that scene. So that means that if Imrahil is in the film, he'll be in a reduced capacity.

[DolAmroth]

What ur saying the muster of rohan is gunna be in the moive but thats impossible cause they do ride to gondor so how could there not be a muster of rohan.

[The Moose]

that's what i was just thinking Dol

[DolAmroth]

I think he is mistaken its impossible for the muster of rohan not to be shown it even shows it in the rotk tralier so hes just wrong.

[KenM]

Originally posted by PsYkOoOoO
ROTK follows the book more closely than the other 2 movies..


I thought the FoTR EE was about as close to the book you could get and still have an enjoyible movie.

[PsYkOoOoO]

im talking abt the theatrical versions

[The Moose]

i think that's what Harrypotterlotr was meaning, the TE not the EE

[adt100]

There are quite a few changes, inevitably, but from all we've seen and heard so far ROTK will be more true to the book in a way FOTR was, compared to TTT.

I'm fine with that, it's the major plot shifts or PJ 'additions' that I'm not as happy with.

[PsYkOoOoO]

well those only happened in TTT and i dont think there will be a lot of addition in ROTK..

[LOTRfan]

there's just no room for them.

[PsYkOoOoO]

exactly..

[Queen Arwen]

Well, in any case, PJ's the man. :)